Know your beef

Prime vs. Choice Beef: What's the Difference?

The short answer: Prime and Choice are USDA quality grades, and the biggest difference between them is marbling, the fine threads of fat inside the meat. USDA describes Prime as having slightly abundant to abundant marbling and Choice as having moderate marbling. More marbling generally means more flavor, moisture and tenderness, so Prime is richer and more forgiving, and it costs more. Choice is still an excellent steak, especially from the rib and the loin.

How USDA beef grading works

USDA quality grades describe the eating quality you can expect, and marbling is the key factor. These are the three grades you'll see in stores:

GradeMarbling, per USDAWhat USDA says
PrimeSlightly abundant to abundantFrom young, well-fed cattle. Ideal for high-heat cooking (broiling, roasting, grilling), because marbling helps keep it moist.
ChoiceModerateSuited to most high-heat methods. Roasts and steaks from the loin and rib are tender, juicy and flavorful; less tender cuts are best braised or simmered.
SelectSlightFairly tender but may be less juicy or flavorful; benefits from marinades or slow, moist cooking.

A grade describes the beef itself, not the brand. That's why brand programs can add their own standards on top of it.

Where Certified Angus Beef® fits in

Certified Angus Beef is a brand, not a USDA grade. According to the brand, cattle must first be Angus-influenced, with a predominantly solid black coat, and the beef must then meet 10 specifications. Those include modest or higher marbling, medium to fine marbling texture, and limits on age, size and fat thickness. The brand says its Prime product meets nine more standards than USDA Prime.

At Grill House we carry Certified Angus Beef in two tiers:

  • Certified Angus Beef® Prime: the brand's Prime product.
  • High Choice: the name we use for our Certified Angus Beef® steaks that aren't Prime. It isn't a separate USDA grade.

Compare the same steak in both tiers

The easiest way to see the difference is to compare one cut at one size. We sell the boneless ribeye and the New York strip in both tiers, in the same 14, 16 and 25 oz sizes, so you can compare like for like: look for more, and finer, flecks of fat through the Prime steak.

Is Prime worth it?

It depends on how you'll cook and serve it.

Choose Prime when the steak is the star of the meal: a celebration, a simple salt-and-pepper sear, or a thick steak cooked to medium-rare, where the extra marbling is something you taste. Marbling also gives you a little more margin if the steak goes slightly past your target.

Choose Choice when you're feeding more people, slicing steak for tacos or salads, using a marinade or a bold sauce, or cooking on a weeknight. A well-cooked Choice ribeye is a great steak.

Cooking tips for both grades

Both grades cook the same way. A few differences to expect:

  • Prime renders more fat. On the grill, expect more dripping and possible flare-ups, so keep a cooler zone to move the steak to.
  • Season to match. Salt and pepper are often enough for Prime. With Choice, a compound butter or a sauce works well.
  • Use a thermometer and rest the steak. USDA's safe minimum internal temperature for beef steaks is 145°F, followed by a 3-minute rest.

Try one of our recipes: Cast Iron New York with Blue Cheese Butter & Crispy Shallots or California Chimichurri Ribeye with Charred Scallions.

Compare them yourself

Frequently asked questions

Is Prime better than Choice?

Prime has more marbling, which USDA links to more flavor, moisture and tenderness. Whether it's "better" depends on the dish. For a simply seasoned steak, Prime shows its advantage. For marinades, slicing or big groups, Choice is often the smarter buy.

What's the difference between Certified Angus Beef and USDA Prime?

USDA Prime is a grade. Certified Angus Beef is a brand with its own 10 specifications. According to the brand, its Prime product meets nine more standards than USDA Prime.

Is "High Choice" a USDA grade?

No. USDA's grades are Prime, Choice and Select. "High Choice" is the name we use for our Certified Angus Beef® steaks that aren't Prime.

Is prime rib always USDA Prime?

No. "Prime rib" is the name of a cut, the rib roast. The grade is a separate question. See How Much Prime Rib Per Person?

Sources

← All resources